Four popular AJAX framework jQuery, Mootools, Dojo, ExtJS contrast

sponsored links
AJAX is the cornerstone of web2.0, and now several popular open source AJAX Web framework, such as: jQuery, Mootools, Dojo, Ext JS and so on, then we in the end under what circumstances the use of that framework? The following is a excerpt of the data:

Ajaxian Ajax tools at the end of 2007, conducted a survey of some results is shown below (which number to use the tool to investigate the percentage of details, see the website): http://ajaxian.com/archives/2007-ajax- tools-usage-survey-results


Prototype


jQuery


Ext


Script.aculo.us


Mootools


YUI


JSON


Dojo


Backbase


34.1%


29.3%


22.5%


22.3%


14.3%


13%


12.9%


11.8%


8.3%


Prototype of which the highest rates, largely because it was the first mature framework, many previously used in the project, so it has been used

Let's take a look at selected based AJAX framework:

Your project needs (ie what features you need, for example, require the interface to make beautiful, special effects, or other functions)
A rating is supported browsers (IE, Firefox, etc.)?
Documentation Quality: is perfect (including tutorials, API, code samples, etc.)
How the scalability of the framework? As a framework to write plug-ins to be easy?
Do you like the style of its API?
Degree of unity to most of the JavaScript code in your style?
Frame size (too large to download the framework of lead time)
Framework is to force you to change the way to write HTML (Dojo is one such)?
Code execution speed: performance?
Whether the code modular (Mootools is a highly modular)? How to reuse code?

A, jQuery
Home: http://jquery.com/


Design
Simple idea: almost all operations are to select DOM elements (a strong Selector), and then to its operation (Chaining and other characteristics).

<br /> Advantages of small, compressed code only 20 k (no compression code 94k).
Selector and the convenience of DOM operations: jQuery's Selector's Element.Selectors.js compared with mootools, CSS Selector, XPath Selector (1.2 post deleted)
Chaining: always returns a jQuery object that can be continuous operation.
Document integrity, ease of use (each API has a complete example, which is now can not be compared to other frameworks), but there are many other online documents and books.
Wide range of applications, including the google code also uses jQuery.

The site uses jQuery: http://docs.jquery.com/Sites_Using_jQuery
The core development team and key personnel: John Resig and so on.
Concise and brief grammar, easy to remember.
Scalability: There are a large number of user-developed plug-ins available ( http://jquery.com/plugins/ )
jQuery UI ( http://jquery.com/plugins/ , based on jQuery, but the core of jQuery and independent), and constantly developing.
Friendly and active community: Google groups: http://docs.jquery.com/Discussion
There are many convenient event handling methods, such as click, rather than a single addEvent and the like.

<br /> The design shortcomings of the pursuit of efficiency and simplicity, not object-oriented extensions. Different design ideas and Mootools.
CSS Selector slightly slower speed (but now has been a substantial increase in speed)

Second, Mootools
Home: http://mootools.net/


Design
Object-oriented design.

Advantages
Modular, each module is independent of the code, the minimum core is only 8k, the biggest advantage is that choose to use which module, when used with the modules can only import complete nor to 180k (no compression), compression is not to 70k.
Syntax is simple and intuitive.
Effects (Effects): This is slightly stronger than jQuery, now being developed Mootools UI (Ajax framework that should be the development of a trend).
Code written in beautiful, easy to read and modify.
The complete document (the document the latest 1.2beta more detailed than before.)
Active community: official website ( http://forum.mootools.net/ ), there is a IRC.
Performance: See: http://mootools.net/slickspeed/

Shortcomings <br /> modified some of the lower classes: such as Array, String, etc. This is also the different design ideas.
On the DOM and CSS Selector in jQuery as powerful.

Third, Dojo
Home: http://dojotoolkit.org/

Advantages
Behind the strong support: IBM, Sun, BEA, etc. It is very important advantage.
Powerful features, Full Stack framework extends the DHTML capabilities such as:
Support and browser Back / Forward button integration.
Dojo Offline, offline storage of a cross-platform API.
Chart component, you can easily generate charts in the browser.
Based on SVG / VML vector graphics library.
Google Maps, Yahoo! Maps components, facilitate the development of Mashup applications.
Comet support, through the common Buyeux agreement.
Powerful UI (Dijit).
Object-oriented design, unified namespace, the package management system (The Package System and Custom Builds)
Scalability.

Defects complex, steep learning curve.
Incomplete documentation of the extreme, this is a big problem.
API lot of instability, the larger the changes between versions, is not yet a mature framework.
Too intrusive, extensive use of dojo page properties, such as <button dojoType="dijit.form.Button">, if in the future to upgrade or switch to a framework dojo, the burden will be great.
Performance problems, due to adopt a synchronous dojo loading mechanism will temporarily lock the browser, causing 100% CPU utilization. In addition, many Widget is very slow.

Fourth, Ext JS
Home: http://extjs.com/

<br /> Component of design to promote the RIA (Rich Internet Application) application.

<br /> Powerful advantages of UI, and good performance, which is its greatest strengths.
Speed control is the UI or other modules.
100% object-oriented and component-oriented thinking, the same syntax, the global namespace.
Document complete, standardized and convenient.
The core development team, Jack Slocum and so on.
Active community, the rapidly increasing volume of users.
Modular implementation, scalability.
All the components (widgets) can be used directly, without having to set (of course, the user can select the re-configuration).

Shortcomings
A little complicated.
Framework for the heavyweight (including a large number of UI), bulky. If the import ext-all.js, compression after nearly 500k.

Note: EXT commercial use: If you just extjs included in their projects, and this project is not sold to the secondary development of the toolbox the user to do, or the component library to LGPL agreement to abide by free; or to pay .

Summary <br /> lightweight choice of lightweight choice: mainly mootools and jquery, because of their different design, jQuery is the pursuit of simplicity and efficiency, Mootools addition to the pursuit of these objectives other than its core is object oriented, Therefore, for rapid development of jQuery, Mootools for a little large and complex projects, which need the support of object-oriented; In addition, support for the Ajax, jQuery slightly stronger; in support of the Comet, jQuery plug-ins are related, Mootools does not have, but the core is the Comet server support, browser interface is very simple, related to the development of plug-in is simple.

In the object-oriented Javascript Library, mootools gradually over the prototype (size large, object-oriented design is unreasonable, etc.), including script.acul.ous (based on prototype, in fact, the UI prototype library).

Framework for RIA

Consider the pure JavaScripty library, the key is Dojo and ExtJS (still YUI). Dojo is more suitable for enterprise applications and product development needs, as offline storage, DataGrid, 2D, 3D graphics, Chart, Comet and other components for enterprise applications, it is very important (of course, these components have to wait some time before stabilized). For example, BEA Mashup technology-based products developed have been used in the Dojo.

ExtJS: beautiful and "easy", and strong enough. In the UI needs a relatively large, is preferred.

posted @ 2009-01-16 Yu Qi
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • TwitThis
  • Mixx
  • Technorati
  • Facebook
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • Google
  • LinkedIn
  • YahooMyWeb

Related Posts of Four popular AJAX framework jQuery, Mootools, Dojo, ExtJS contrast

  • Struts + Spring + Hibernate practice

    Tools: Eclipse3.1, MyEclipse4.03, Tomcat5.5.9, Properties Editor plug-ins, MySql4.1.13 New construction: the name for the login Create Struts framework Create index.jsp, add a link to login.jsp Press Ctrl + N, to create login.jsp, LoginAction, the use of

  • extjs development environment set up and practice

    1, download and extract the extjs 2, download eclipse and Eclipse AJAX Toolkit Framework (ATF) I have been accustomed to using eclipse as a development environment, a variety of open-source plugin so that eclipse has all-around performance, operating effi

  • ajax overtime

    ajax overtime

  • Msxml2.XMLHTTP version problem

    Projects with an import feature prototype.js of Ajax functionality to update the prompt, the code is very simple, do not have the framework of the background on a jsp to output Text, future use of timers and to update the page Ajax.request encountere ...

  • Depth understanding of the eval function in javascript

    http://wanyij.blog.51cto.com/46570/43794 In this paper, the discovery of an appropriate title is not so easy, huh, huh, so in this note under the first two purposes of this article: (1) introduction of the eval function in javascript usage (2) how to func

  • JS after ajax request return of the problem can not be implemented

    1: Send ajax request, in the onComplete, if back when the html contains a javascript, then these javascrip and will not be realized, it does not mean not to implement. This problem has troubled me for a long time, behind the hair and then put this kn ...

  • jBPM Development Getting Started Guide

    Although the workflow is still immature stage of development, not even a recognized standard. But its application has already been launched in the Express, indicating the market's demand for job-flow framework are urgent and enormous. Backgrounds of o

  • Openfire Plugin Developer's Guide

    Introduction Openfire features plug-ins are enhanced. This document is a guide to developers to create plug-ins. The structure of a plug-in Plug-ins Plug-ins openfireHome stored in the directory. When deploying a plug-in jar or war file, it will automatic

  • JS charts extjs implementation tools can be combined

    OpenFlashChart brief introduction by valensoft 2009-1-10 8:29:00 OpenFlashChart is an open source Flash and Javascript to the technical foundation for the free chart, using it to create some very useful analysis of the effect of the statements of the char

  • Dynamic loading JS script four kinds of methods

    To achieve dynamic loading JS script has four kinds of methods: 1, direct document.write <script language="javascript"> document.write ( "<script src='test.js'> <\ / script>"); </ script> 2, dynamic scri

blog comments powered by Disqus
Recent
Recent Entries
Tag Cloud
Random Entries